We visited the Athenian House with very high expectations, given the numerous positive reviews we had read. Most of the times when I go somewhere with such high expectations, reality hits me hard and I get disappointed with the end result; this was not the case with the Athenian House.
Everything and everyone helped us in making this one of the best dinners of our lives. Starting with the location itself which is breathtaking with one of the best views (I dare say worldwide), going to the service which is extremely professional and tentative making sure that everyone enjoys their dinner, to the hosts who try to make you feel as if you were guest at their house.
The best thing about the Athenian House however is the most important factor when judging a restaurant: the food itself.
Everything we ordered was exquisitely prepared. Starting from the "cheese pie" with 3 different cheeses from nearby islands, going to the smoked fava bean purée with white truffle and caramelised onions, to the updated version of the "Athinaiki salad which are all brilliant starters. Next stop the main courses with probably one of the best vegetarian dishes you can find anywhere in Greece, the "white aubergine risotto". Their version of the (probably most famous Greek dish) moussaka, is spectacular; modern yet so true to itself. Finally, the desserts will make you feel guilt for having to spend an extra hour of swimming the next day to get rid of those calories but they are so worth it. Do try their version of the baklava, with a peanut butter/chocolate mousse between sheets of caramelised pastry and salted caramel!
To accompany your dinner you can chose one of the three cocktails all of which are prepared with local spirits. Following that you can trust the restaurant's sommelier's proposal. All offered wines are really worth trying but I would insist on trying one of the local varieties and especially the "Asyrtiko", the grape variety Santorini is becoming world famous for.
All in all, it's a truly unique experience and is worth cashing out for one night as this is something you will probably never experience again.