The fish was very nice - the chips were ok but definitely not exceptional. The price was great for Iceland.
I would have given a four but the service was just so cold. Hard to get their attention and then hard to get an answer from them when I did.

Simple set up and really great fish! Had the breaded cod and roasted potatoes and it was sublime. Located centrally and near the harbour so plenty of other temptations around too.

Arrived in Iceland and wanted some of their Cod fish that we had heard so much about. We asked for recommendations at our hotel & were given several places. We chose to walk to Icelandic Fish & Chips near the water. Our Cod was SO GREASY- would have liked to have had paper towels to absorb some of the grease. Not very tasty at all either. The roasted Rosemary/Garlic potatoes were good.. We each ordered a salad and the lettuce was old, yellow/brown Iceberg Lettuce. We couldn't believe how terrible it looked. Maybe it was the long trip across the Atlantic. We also ordered tartar sauce to go with our fish, not knowing how expensive the tiny jigger would be. It was our first meal (LUNCH) on the first day of our week in Iceland, so when we walked up to the counter to pay, we got our first SHOCK of what we were in for as far as eating in Iceland. Our lunch cost $72.00 (u.s. dollars) let me add---we drank WATER....Come to find out, we had very delicious meals throughout our vacation, and NEVER once paid that much for any of the meals---even dinner meals. In fact, while walking through the streets of Reykjavik one evening, we came upon a beautiful restaurant and their special that night was an incredible COD dish/ salad included, for the unbelievable price of $20.00 u.s.dollars (the romantic atmosphere was worth the $20.00 itself).... My advice---save some money, while getting better food for less, before getting robbed at this Fish & Chips.

Extremely fresh fish dipped in spelt batter and fried; not greasy. Good dipping sauces. Service was tentative and confused.

Tourist trap.

Menu does NOT imply in any way that the chips are priced as a separate item to the fish. INSANELY expensive and NOT real chips but some kind of microwaved then highly salted roasted potatoes.

Batter is super odd and also over salted.

How can the name "fish and chips" possibly justify that the potatoes are a separate item. Love fish and chips and have literally traveled the globe and sampled them in many locations but have NEVER EVER been charged individually.

What is even more annoying is that as i was checking out a lady showed me a coupon on her phone and suggested i get the app - the English speaking check out person (as was the server - no language barriers or miscommunications here) said no, i wouldn't be able to use that app as she showed it to me and then had the nerve to show me a paper coupon and said i could have used one of those so requested one and he said NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Do your self and your wallet a favor and find somewhere else to eat!