Teenager with us particularly wants to see sites from American Horror Story, want a good non-cheesy tour!
I would check out the AHS stuff on your own (download the google map) and do the 5-in-1 haunted tour with Voodoo Bone Lady Tours. Our guide, Michael, was awesome and very knowledgeable on the haunted history of Nola. During this tour, we did make a stop at the LaLaurie House (from the Coven season).
The Phantom one was great and saw a few things from Coven :)