We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows:
Internet Explorer
,
Mozilla Firefox
,
Google Chrome
. Mac:
Safari
.
Atlantic Highlands
Atlantic Highlands Tourism
Atlantic Highlands Hotels
Flights to Atlantic Highlands
Atlantic Highlands Restaurants
Things to Do in Atlantic Highlands
Atlantic Highlands Travel Forum
Atlantic Highlands Photos
Atlantic Highlands Map
All Atlantic Highlands Hotels
Atlantic Highlands Hotel Deals
By Hotel Type
Atlantic Highlands Business Hotels
Atlantic Highlands Spa Resorts
Romantic Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
By Hotel Class
5-stars Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
3-stars Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
Near Landmarks
Hotels near Seastreak Ferry
Hotels near Mount Mitchill Scenic Overlook
Hotels near Atlantic Highlands Arts Council
Hotels near Jungle Jim and Jane
Hotels near Atlantic Highlands Historical Society
Hotels near Clearwater Baseball Fields
All Atlantic Highlands Restaurants
Popular Dishes
Best Meatballs in Atlantic Highlands
Best Crab in Atlantic Highlands
Best Nachos in Atlantic Highlands
Best Oyster in Atlantic Highlands
Best Fajitas in Atlantic Highlands
Best Risotto in Atlantic Highlands
Best Scallops in Atlantic Highlands
Best Chowder in Atlantic Highlands
Best Wings in Atlantic Highlands
Best Crab Cakes in Atlantic Highlands
Best Pasta in Atlantic Highlands
Best Salad in Atlantic Highlands
Best Cheesesteaks in Atlantic Highlands
Best Pancakes in Atlantic Highlands
Best Bagels in Atlantic Highlands
Near Hotels
Restaurants near Oyster Point Hotel
Restaurants near SummerHouse
Restaurants near Molly Pitcher Inn
Restaurants near BeachWalk at Sea Bright
Restaurants near SeaScape Manor Bed & Breakfast
Restaurants near The Hub Middletown - Best Western Signature Collection Hotel
Restaurants near Leonardo Motel
Near Landmarks
Restaurants near Seastreak Ferry
Restaurants near Atlantic Cinemas
Restaurants near First Avenue Playhouse Dessert Theatre
Restaurants near Mount Mitchill Scenic Overlook
Restaurants near Carton Brewing Company
Restaurants near Classic Boat Rides
Restaurants near Atlantic Star Fishing
Restaurants near Fair Mountain Coffee Roasters
Restaurants near Twin Lights Historic Site
Restaurants near Gateway National Recreation Area
Near Restaurants
Restaurants near Copper Canyon
Restaurants near Christines Italian
Restaurants near Harborside Grill
Skip to main content
Discover
Trips
Review
More
PHP
Sign in
Inbox
See all
Sign in
to get trip updates and message other travelers.
Atlantic Highlands
Hotels
Things to Do
Restaurants
Flights
Travel Stories
Cruises
Tours
Add a Place
Travel Forum
Airlines
Travelers' Choice
Help Center
THE 10 BEST Restaurants Near Blue Bay Inn, Atlantic Highlands
United States
New Jersey (NJ)
Jersey Shore
Atlantic Highlands
Atlantic Highlands Restaurants
Restaurants near Blue Bay Inn
Search
Restaurants near Blue Bay Inn
51 1st Ave
,
near Sandy Hook beach and sea streak fast ferry
,
Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716-1242
Read Reviews of
Blue Bay Inn
Sponsored
Triumph Brewing Co. of Red Bank
26 reviews
1 Bridge Ave
“Amazing September Wedding at Triumph”
10/16/2022
“Awesome vibe”
04/03/2022
Cuisines:
American
Bar
Brew Pub
Pub
Seafood
Find a table
Copper Canyon
#14 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
179 reviews
51 1st Ave
0 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Blown Away
”
06/22/2022
“
Definitely not the same .... v...
”
06/07/2021
Cuisines:
Southwestern
Order Online
Higo Restaurant & Lounge
#21 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
4 reviews
51 1st Ave
0 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
My new favorite place
”
02/29/2020
“
Asian fusion extraordinaire
”
01/14/2020
Cuisines:
Sushi
,
Asian
,
Thai
,
Korean
,
Vietnamese
Christines Italian
#1 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
124 reviews
42 1st Ave
0 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Excellent food, service & atmo...
”
01/19/2024
“
A little Gem!
”
01/04/2024
Cuisines:
Italian
Gas Light
#11 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
43 reviews
33 1st Ave
0 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Great food with special delive...
”
01/21/2020
“
yuck
”
09/11/2019
Cuisines:
American
, Bar, Pub
Hudson Cafe
#7 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
30 reviews
25 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Hudson Cafe - Aloha in NJ
”
07/28/2021
“
Excellent coffee
”
10/13/2019
Cuisines:
American
,
Cafe
The Wine Bar
#8 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
49 reviews
40 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Six of us went to The Wine
”
01/26/2020
“
Great for a Party
”
10/15/2019
Cuisines:
Wine Bar,
International
Harborside Grill
#15 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
66 reviews
40 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Extremely rude bartender.
”
06/05/2022
“
THE BEST BURGERS
”
10/12/2021
Cuisines:
American
The Atlantic House
#17 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
13 reviews
67 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Stick to the bar and appetizer...
”
09/01/2023
“
Exceptional Service
”
05/15/2022
Cuisines:
American
, Bar,
Seafood
, Pub
Reserve
Nicholas Creamery
#9 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
15 reviews
84 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
great ice cream
”
11/12/2022
“
Awesome Fresh Ice Cream
”
08/19/2021
Town & Surf Diner
#10 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
26 reviews
77 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Not bad, slow service.
”
12/19/2021
“
Not the place it use to be...
”
07/08/2019
Cuisines:
American
, Diner
Monty's BBQ
#12 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
7 reviews
71 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
great food
”
06/19/2023
“
Surprisingly Great BBQ in NJ
”
12/27/2022
Cuisines:
Barbecue
Order Online
Atlantic Bagel Company
#13 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
25 reviews
74 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Great Bagels
”
12/27/2022
“
Bagels like I remember........
”
01/14/2020
Cuisines:
American
,
Cafe
Order Online
Gianni's Italian Specialty Food
#16 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
13 reviews
71 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Absolutely fantastic
”
09/05/2021
“
Consistently good food
”
02/05/2018
Cuisines:
Italian
,
Pizza
,
Deli
Pomodoro Rosso Italian Grill & Pizzeria
#20 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
9 reviews
State Highway 36 & 1st. Ave 5 Bayshore Plaza Shopping Center
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Best pizza in town
”
11/15/2022
“
Don't bother
”
10/12/2021
Cuisines:
Italian
,
Pizza
Order Online
Kunya Siam
#3 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
103 reviews
99 1st Ave
0.2 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Soup was very good.
”
08/20/2023
“
Annoyed
”
05/15/2022
Cuisines:
Asian
,
Thai
Strada Pizza Bar
#31 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
7 reviews
91 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
The miserable owner is in the...
”
08/11/2023
“
Best restaurant in the area.
”
07/08/2023
Cuisines:
Italian
,
Pizza
On the Deck Restaurant
#2 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
217 reviews
10 Simon Lake Dr Atlantic Highlands Marina
0.4 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Great find!
”
09/08/2023
“
Absolutely Delicious!
”
08/06/2023
Cuisines:
American
, Bar,
Seafood
Sissy's at the Harbor
#6 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
68 reviews
8 Simon Lake Dr
0.3 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
A great place for breakfast.
”
07/23/2023
“
Bring CASH and PATIENCE to Sis...
”
09/11/2022
Cuisines:
American
Zoe's Vintage Kitchen
#5 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
64 reviews
77 Center Ave
0.3 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
lunch
”
09/21/2020
“
A Weekly Tradition
”
10/15/2019
Cuisines:
American
Order Online
JUS Organic
#23 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
5 reviews
135 First Ave
0.3 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Easy casual good!
”
01/04/2022
“
Love Love Love
”
06/21/2020
Cuisines:
Cafe
,
Healthy
Philly's Famous Cheesesteaks
#25 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
7 reviews
1 West Ave
0.4 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Owner is very nice but food is...
”
10/05/2017
“
Best cheesesteak ever!
”
04/23/2017
Cuisines:
Italian
,
American
,
Steakhouse
Mike's Dairy and Deli
#29 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
2 reviews
160 1st Ave
0.5 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
convenience store
”
03/22/2017
“
Great Food, Great Prices, Grea...
”
09/29/2016
Jersey Mike's Subs
#22 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
5 reviews
7 Bayshore Plaza
0.6 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Only Place to go for Subs
”
07/25/2019
“
Great eats and service
”
10/05/2017
Order Online
Domino's Pizza
#30 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
2 reviews
183 First Ave
0.6 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Usually ok but not today
”
07/16/2019
“
It's a Dominoes
”
11/19/2016
Cuisines:
Pizza
Julio's Pizza Co.
Be the first to review this restaurant
75 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
Order Online
Atlantic Highlands Towne Diner
Be the first to review this restaurant
77 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
Cheng's Garden Chinese Restaurant
Be the first to review this restaurant
80 1st Ave
0.1 km
from Blue Bay Inn
1st Cup Coffee
Be the first to review this restaurant
96 1st Ave
0.2 km
from Blue Bay Inn
36 West Bar and Restaurant
#26 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
2 reviews
965 State Route 36
0.9 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
Dinner was great.
”
08/09/2016
“
What a Fabulous find - Great F...
”
06/06/2016
Cuisines:
American
McDonald's
#27 of 31 Restaurants in Atlantic Highlands
6 reviews
970 State Route 36
0.9 km
from Blue Bay Inn
“
They bring your food to your t...
”
11/10/2017
“
Inappropriate Review request
”
09/29/2017
Order Online
1-30
of
200
«
1
2
...
7
»
Map of Blue Bay Inn
Things to Do
(21)
|
Restaurants
(40)
Also show
Hotels
Things to Do
Also show
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Return to Map
Hotels travelers are raving about...
The Hub Middletown - Best Western Signature Collection Hotel
35 Reviews
Read reviews
Middletown, NJ
BeachWalk at Sea Bright
180 Reviews
Read reviews
Sea Bright, Jersey Shore
Oyster Point Hotel
426 Reviews
Read reviews
Red Bank, NJ
Molly Pitcher Inn
611 Reviews
Read reviews
Red Bank, NJ
Courtyard by Marriott Lincroft Red Bank
407 Reviews
Read reviews
Red Bank, NJ
Extended Stay America - Red Bank - Middletown
292 Reviews
Read reviews
Red Bank, NJ
More
Holiday Inn Hazlet, an IHG Hotel
257 Reviews
Read reviews
Hazlet, NJ
Best Western Hazlet Inn
486 Reviews
Read reviews
Hazlet, NJ
SeaScape Manor Bed & Breakfast
81 Reviews
Read reviews
Highlands, Jersey Shore
Less
All hotels in Atlantic Highlands
(1)