Much of the evening was great, but two big problems. The risotto with my scallops was half uncooked, and the crust on the pizza ordered by two of our party was raw. We told the server about it, but said we'd just live with it....She apologized, but we never got the sense she told anyone or really cared. And there was certainly no apology or any comp'ing of a dessert or anything at the end.More

We were disappointed (twice) several years ago but thought we’d give it another chance. Seated in a back room. 20 minutes later I went looking for someone to wait on us. 5 minutes later ordered. 10 minutes later got a thimble full of wine. Dinner...entrees (salads) were 30 minutes later. Food was below average. No atmosphere...lights in back room made it like a cafeteria. No blame to the servers...where is management in this restaurant. $60 for 2 salads and a LOT of waiting.More

Best restaurant in area with a fabulous wine list. Visit there any chance we can. Great pizza, great food, nice bar with great atmosphere.

My wife and I visited Vintage for another time, this time after the Coronavirus. Very good precautions including direction arrows and distance seating. Very good meals and service. Nicely done by staff. This was on a Friday evening, and they were busy.

Great Pizza which was too much for a single person plus great service!! I travel to Elkins often so I will definitely return.

I have never been disappointed with anything I have ever ordered here. I always try something new. You must try all their appetizers.

We stopped here tonight for an early dinner. We shared the hummus. It was super delicious. The hummus was a pleasa t suprise. It was jazzed up with a few veggies and feta. Then we shared one of their famous pizzas. Super yummy crust and...toppings. We left very full and very satisfied. 🙂More

First and foremost, the "Paulie" pizza may have ruined pizza for me for life! That's how good it was!!! But there was also beautiful live music; our waiter, Nathan, was amazing and super attentive; the tortellini and cobbler were delicious and the atmosphere is extremely...pleasant. If you are ever in Elkins, WV this is where you want to have dinner for sure!More

Went to meet relatives there for dinner. Great food and atmosphere. Met the owner and his wife. Great people and great place.

Stopped in for a late lunch and had appetizers and pizza. The brick oven pizza was done perfectly and the crust was very flavorful. There was a nice assorment of appetizers and the two our table had were very good. The service was also outstanding....Our server was very knowledgeable about the menu and when my wife and I decided to split a beer, she brought back two poured glasses with equal amounts in both (so we did not have to fight over who got more!) If you are in Elkins - make this one of your stops. The inside decor was very nicely done.More

Change our plans for the evening. Wife ordered the trout. Was prepared fantastic. The portion was oversized. I ordered the Ribeye steak. It was excellent. Would definitely recommend.

We ate here one night on our roadtrip the food was nice, 2 pizzas wich tasted very good would go again !