We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Ratings and reviews

RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Details

CUISINES
American
FEATURES
Takeout, Seating
Reviews (64)
Filter reviews
64 results
Traveler rating
52
6
4
1
1
Traveler type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveler rating
52
6
4
1
1
See what travelers are saying:
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed March 10, 2019 via mobile

Waiting to try! This was our 3rd bakery North of indy! All were different. Girls were nice and place was clean. Love the delivery trucks

Date of visit: March 2019
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed February 3, 2019

You better order your holiday pies early! My Sugar Pie started as a booth at Saturday morning farmers' market near Main Street in Zionsville many years ago. It was so popular that the proprietor opened a shop nearby. On holidays patrons line up outside the...shop to pick up their pre-ordered pies. Our favorites are the apple pies, but all are delicious. The crust is flaky and the filling tasty. Slices of pie are also available. The cost is a little high, but you can get a little rebate by returning the plate.More

Date of visit: December 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed September 5, 2018

We ordered My Sugar Pie for our wedding pie (pie is my favorite dessert, much preferred to cake!) and I'm so happy we did! Kelly is wonderful to work with and her pies are THE BEST. Our pie tasting was scheduled for first thing in...the morning and it was a dream come true -- pie for breakfast! We ordered the Dutch Apple (my favorite), peach blueberry, key lime, and sugar cream pie. Our friends and family loved the pie so much that we had a pie party (with coffee and champagne) the day after the wedding with our leftover pies. Thank you so much for making our day extra sweet!More

Date of visit: February 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed August 27, 2018

Everyone should experience a My Sugar Pie for desert at some point. This is on the desert menu at St Elmo's Steakhouse. A bit pricey but I've never seen any leftovers. Dutch Apple or Chocolate are my favorites but a scoop of ice cream on...a warm piece of Peach Pie will put a smile on your face.More

Date of visit: August 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed August 7, 2018

We celebrate ESPN's college game day every Saturday and I have used My Sugar Pie as the "go to" place for dessert! They have a pie that represnts almost every state! They have the best sugar cream & apple pies!

Date of visit: September 2017
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed August 7, 2018

My wife is the best baker in the state of Georgia, so when she saw this bakery, she had to try it out. We ended up getting a slice of three different pies and ate them over the following few days. I'm not sure they...are healthy, but you don't eat this sort of thing to stay in shape.More

Date of visit: August 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed August 6, 2018

I don't believe dining in the store is all that easy but their product is showcased at most of the eateries n the Zionsville area. And it is good. Very good. When I am at a restaurant that carries their pies, I am always a...little anxious to see if they have my favorite - cherry pie. It is fabulous!More

Date of visit: August 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed June 19, 2018

I am not a sugar cream pie person and this one is to die for. Highly recommend! Not overly sweet. The only thing bad about this this now i have to become a regular pie customer =) and they ship.

Date of visit: May 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed April 2, 2018 via mobile

“Just order one from My Sugar Pie and thank me later”. Seems I say this a lot and then I hear how great it was. Kelly and her team make the best pies. We ship Sugar Cream Pies (well they do for us) twice a...year to my father in law in Florida. Yes it’s a family affair!More

Date of visit: April 2018
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
Reviewed September 7, 2017 via mobile

Incredible Pies! Must try Dutch apple and sugar cream pie. These are great to give as thank you gifts too. They ship if you are looking to send one to someone special!

Date of visit: September 2017
Helpful?
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews.
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis North - Carmel, an IHG Hotel
87 reviews
3.56 km away
Homewood Suites by Hilton Indianapolis Northwest
571 reviews
3.93 km away
Red Roof Inn Indianapolis North - College Park
232 reviews
4.02 km away
Extended Stay America - Indianapolis - North - Carmel
115 reviews
4.06 km away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
The Friendly Tavern
398 reviews
.09 km away
Noah Grant's
214 reviews
.11 km away
Salty Cowboy
161 reviews
.09 km away
Rosies
170 reviews
.17 km away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Hopwood Cellars Winery
50 reviews
.19 km away
Grapevine Cottage
24 reviews
.12 km away
Zionsville Farmers Market
32 reviews
.10 km away
Fanimation Antique Fan Museum
15 reviews
1.44 km away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from My Sugar Pie staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Submit
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about My Sugar Pie

Yes, My Sugar Pie offers takeout services.

My Sugar Pie is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers:
  • Food: 5
  • Service: 4.5
  • Value: 4
  • Atmosphere: 4