We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
COVID-19 update: See the added health and safety measures this property is taking.Read more
All photos (135)
All photos (135)
What is Travelers’ Choice?
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
All reviews pizza homemade hummus salad breadsticks pie blt grateful bread wood fire absolutely love this place well worth the wait cool vibe thin crust take out marinara sauce cold beer north georgia friday night
Sorry that I can't give a rating. Closed due to staffing issues according to the message. A group of buddies had met for a weekend and pizza was a convenient solution for dinner the first night. Disappointed.
Ordered pizza & Chet stix yo go. We are staying in Blue Ridge, GA on vacation. We prefer to visit local brick and mortars over chains. The pizza was good, loved the red onions. Not the type of pizza we are used to! However, we...would def come back when in the area, and likely dine in vs. taking it to go. Reasonable price and service was very good. I wish the website explained there is only one size;
14” ;as the poor waitress had to say it to me and the call she took following checking me out! 😋More
Unicorns, mermaids and leprechauns would have their dreams shattered here. This place is an old, run down, cheap pizza parlor that's in a shopping center that has an old skating rink/putt putt vibe. I'm all about hippie vibes and funky decorations, but they really missed...the mark on this one. It has tacky decor that isn't well done and everything feels/looks dirty. The service was bad, our cheese pizza took almost an hour and a half to get to our table in this small, yet busy restraunt. We kept on trying to get our tab and a Togo box. I finally hopped up, got my own Togo box...and then we waited another 15 minutes at the front to pay our tab. The Togo orders were out the door and a lady kept running around saying, "I'll be with you guys in just a minute." We finally just put cash on the tab and walked out the door. If I were you, I would just throw out the peace sign and keep driving past this restaurant.
P.s. I have included the owner’s response to my review of the restaraunt in my photos. Apparently, the owner of this establishment has a reputation of leaving rude responses to people’s reviews.More
The summer salad was one of the best things I’ve eaten in Blue Ridge. And the veggie pizza is great! The service is quick and friendly, and the quirky decor makes this place a lot of fun. I’ll definitely come back.
Stayed at a cabin right up the mountain from Mystic Mountain Pizza. Southern Comfort Cabin Rentals left a welcome package including suggestions on local places to eat. Mystic Mountain Pizza was highly recommended by them and previous cabin guests so we gave it a try!...Funky, fun atmosphere, delicious pizza (perfect crust, fresh toppings!), and wonderful service even though it was crazy busy. We can’t wait to return soon to try different menu items!More
I'm a huge pizza snob and Mystic Mountain is how it should be done. The ingredients were top notch, the cheese was flavorful, the sauce was robust, the char on the bottom crust was just enough, and the crust as a whole was a little...chewy and had a nice taste. Up there with the best I've ever had, and I've tried a lot. Hard to see anyone being disappointed, regardless of their personal criteria. The people were great too, and the service was attentive. Highly recommend it and I look forward to going back next time I'm in the area.More
Date of visit: November 2021
krazijs4, Owner at Mystic Mountain Pizza, responded to this reviewResponded November 28, 2021
Kevin you are our perfect guest this is such an amazing complement and it validates all of our blood sweat and tears that we put into this place not in the pizza so we’re good there. Bless you for taking time out of your busy...More