This Irish restaurant/pub never disappoints. The Shepherd's pie and Chicken pot pie are delicious. It has a friendly atmosphere and the wait staff is attentive and helpful. Highly recommended.
1 - 10 of 80 reviews
Usually McCarthy’s is one of best spots for great Irish food; but lunches are new and lacking. No Irish Stew!!! I had the lunch special which was a grilled cheese sandwich and cup of soup; which came to over $13 (no drink, just water). The...More
It been long over due and I really enjoy McCarthys. Everything we had on menu was excellent. The chicken pot pie is of course great, but Sheppard's pie, scotch eggs and Irish stew. They also have burger and NY steak sandwich for those who are...More
For months I kept hearing about this Chicken Pot Pie, but as that's not a big food choice for me, I didn't make the effort to try this pub. But I was in the area with friends, so thought why not, and I'm happy I...More
I never knew chicken pot pie wa Irish. I don't even care but this is a dish that's incredible. They put it together table side. Puffy crust and a lot of chicken. They also have a burger that you have to try. They also have...More
Have visited several times, they have a Bar and a separate restaurant. The Chicken Pot Pie is the best I have ever had. The Service is with a smile and so professional. It is a well run Bar / Restaurant that truly care about their...More
Known for Chicken Pot pie. Good Sheppard's pie, lamb stew but good American dishes also. Good bar music Fridays. Packed house with sing a longs.
Tuesday special: Roast turkey dinner with stuffing, mashed, sweet pots, gravy and cranberry jelly. Yum!!! Chocolate crème pie for dessert was fabulous. Thin crust, chocolate filling and delicious topping. Perfection. Glad to have McCarthy's back; hope they expand their menu to include sliced lamb dinner...More