Because our experience in parts was amazing and in other parts incredibly disappointing I am unusually going to start this review with a summery so you don't have to read the full rant below unless you really you want to. So to summaries we will not be staying in this or any other Rocco Forte Hotel ever again. We have stayed in other hotels in Edinburgh where the rooms were just as nice, the service much more personal and the rooms were considerably less expensive, and had no hidden costs that you are guilted into paying for. That being said we will be back to the Brasserie Prince and for afternoon tea at the palm court as these experience were so good I will remember them for the rest of my life. We found this hotel to be a bit of a mixed bag, when we visited it recently for my Wife's birthday. I will start with the positives. The afternoon tea in Palm Court, was amazing and felt very special indeed. The choice of teas was mind blowing and the food even better. I had mentioned in advance that it was my Wife's birthday, they brought out the cakes with a candle in and the harpist (that was playing lovely background music) played Happy Birthday To You, which absolutely made the experience for us. We had dinner in Brasserie Prince which is attached to the hotel and I would have to say I cannot think of an occasion when I have ever had a better dinning experience. The food was out of this world and the service was amazing, simply second to none. Again they remembered that it was my Wife's birthday and gave us both a glass of champagne on the house. My Wife had two Spa treatments and she raved about them for days afterwards to anyone who would listen. She said to me repeatedly that they were by far the best spa treatments she had ever had. The hotel on the other hand was a complete disappointment. Not one member of staff wished my Wife a happy Birthday despite me making sure this was mentioned on the booking and again when we checked in (which seemed to come as a surprise to the checking staff). I had upgraded my booking from an executive double to a junior suite, on-line about a month prior to arrival. This upgrade seemed to have been lost in the ether. I did not want to make a fuss in front of my Wife so had to accept this mistake. Although when I did report this to the check-in staff, I was offered a Junior Suite at an additional expense but by this stage my Wife had unpacked and I did not want to have to make her move rooms. My wife tried to use the hair dryer in the room, but it fell apart halfway through drying her hair and sucked her hair in through the back of the hair dryer. This then took quite a bit of time and pain to extract her hair from it. Then we come to the overall experience, which to me was ruined by the blatant attempts to try and extract as much money from there guests as possible. I first noticed this when I went to use the TV in the room, while my Wife had a treatment in the spa. The TV was obviously a modern smart TV with all the smart capabilities disabled. However there was a selection of films you could purchase through the TV. These films were not particularly modern and were being charged at £12.99 a film or £59 for all the films you could watch in 24 hours. I watch a film on my phone through Netflix, which I would much rather have watched on the big screen TV in the room. This experience followed me all the way to check out where I found a £49 charge for room service, which we had not used. When I queried this they advised it was for cleaning the room before we arrived. Although I was advised that it could be taken off, the lady on the check in desk made me feel that I would only take this off if I was not happy with the cleanliness of the room. I have stayed at other high end hotels before and have never heard of a charge like this. You would think at over £800 a night for our room this would be included! They should be very glad of Palm Court and the Brasserie otherwise the rating for this review would be considerably lower.…
I had a recent stay at the Balmoral Hotel in Edinburgh on the day of my wedding. I felt the overall experience we had was a real let down on our special day. We phoned 3 or 4 times prior to our visit to ensure the room would be ready for our earlier arrival on the 14th April 2022, to allow us to get changed. Our wedding was due to start at 12 noon. Reception confirmed on each occasion via phone that this would be no problem, and they'd be able to sort something for us. We arrived around 10am, as previously agreed, and the room was not ready. This was of course very inconvenient, given we also had our 7 month old son with us too. We then had to wait in reception with our luggage until 11.30am, before we gave up, and got changed in the toilets. This really upset my wife, as she didn't have time to properly get ready for her wedding. We were both 20 minutes late for the wedding at the City Chambers, which was very embarrassing, and we didn't have time to take pictures with our family before it started. At no time were we given an alternative area to get ready and feed/change our son, so we had to do this in reception. I asked politely twice to be given access to our room even though it was vacant, but wasn't cleaned, but the receptionist refused. In general, we found there to be loads of staff, eager to help, but not actually helping. Our experience at the Balmoral really spoiled the morning of our wedding, and really didn't expect this to happen given its reputation. When we did get into the room, there was no cot for our son, despite it being requested. Little things such as spelling my wife's new surname wrong, showed poor attention to detail, and really didn't leave a good impression. There are better hotels for less money in the Edinburgh area. I am just so disappointed in the Balmoral. They said the early entry would not be guaranteed when I complained to central office, but the reception confirmed they would be able to help us in some way.…
Last week, I decided to splash out for a night on what I thought would be a top experience at The Balmoral in Edinburgh.......it certainly wasn't what I expected. The hotel is nice (I've stayed in better for less money) and it's in an OK position, although Edinburgh Old Town may have been a better choice. The reason for the low score is that when you are paying £577 for the night (including breakfast) you have certain expectations......for example, for the doorman to help you with your bags, or for the hotel to offer to take your bags to the room. Neither of these things happened. Not that I would have accepted it, but I certainly expected to be asked. The room we were given wasn't big enough to open and layout 2 suitcases and the view was looking at the centre of the hotel which was basically brick. I would expect this if you book through a third-party site, but I booked directly with the hotel so that they got all of my money and they did not have to pay a third party company commission. On checking out, I was given a bill with a line item stating "Service Charge Rooms" for the sum of £24.75. I queried this and was told that it was new and that this is for the maids to service the room!!!! Isn't that why you pay the hotel anyway!!! I was extremely annoyed by this, given the experience was nothing like I had hoped it would be. My strong advice to anybody reading this is to save your money and stay somewhere where they care about your custom. Finally, I have often read bad reviews and thought that the person writing them was being unreasonable.......I am certainly not one of those people, but for the expense of this hotel I did expect certain things…
Enjoyed afternoon tea in the palm court, everything from ambience, food, service, attention to detail was simply perfect. A fantastic experience that I will hopefully experience again. Prior to afternoon tea we had cocktails in the bar which was average
It was a very lovely hotel with a friendly staff. The spa was simple and peaceful. We were there for our honeymoon and got an upgrade to a top floor room. The room was stunning however there was a few visible damages in the bathroom. In a five star hotel I would prefer those things to be kept up with. The turn down service was a welcoming surprise when we returned from our dinner.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Listing