This review is not for CTPH Tours, but rather for the establishment that offers these whale shark experiences in Lila. I could not find a direct site to leave my review, and travelers should be aware of what the actual experience is.
Do not support Bohol Taug whale shark watching in Lila! Swimming with whale sharks is an extraordinary experience that I highly recommend you put on your bucket list, but this IS NOT THE PLACE TO DO IT. This is a tourist trap where they canoe mass numbers of people to a spot right off shore where they have employees hand-feeding the whale sharks. They have buoy lines that encourage tourists to remain in a small area, which the sharks swim through and stop in to get fed. This is not a natural way to see these incredible creatures. It’s disruptive to their migratory patterns and hurts the local ecosystem.
I had heard of what goes on in Oslob and knew I didn’t want to support such unethical practices. I had trouble finding reviews for the tours offered in Lila in Bohol. Some had said to experience swimming with the whale sharks in Bohol before it turns into Oslob, and I had read that whale shark sightings aren’t guaranteed there. Both of these led me to believe the excursions were still being done ethically, but I was very disappointed to discover first-hand that the Taug Whale Shark tours are doing the same activities as what’s going on in Oslob. Here’s a summary of the experience:
We arrived at 6:00 am when they opened to discover there were already about 50 people there waiting to go out to the sharks. We were given a group number and waited about twenty minutes before being called, though about eight groups seemed to be called at the same time. This meant that even though they only loaded each canoe with about 10 people, there were six to eight canoes all going to the same location at the same time, putting a large number of people in the water. We were given a briefing on rules prior to loading the canoes, which made it seem like they were acting in the best interest of the whale sharks. Don’t wear sunscreen. Good. Stay a certain distance away from them. Good. Don’t swim on top or underneath them. Good. Don’t touch them. Good.
All of this seemed like it could still be fine until they brought you out to the site, maybe 100 feet from shore. The buoy lines they placed corralled a large number of tourists into a small area, which limited anyone’s ability to follow the rules. You were forced into groups with the masses, which made it difficult to get out of the way and move around freely in the water. All the rules about keeping distance from the whale sharks were no longer enforceable because they were feeding the whale sharks. The sharks would swim in, and you weren’t always able to maintain the stated distance or even get out of their way. People were trying to tread water and move away but accidentally kicking the sharks. The best thing to do was to hang out on the outskirts of the boundary lines where tourists weren’t all gathered. While I never felt we were in danger from the whale sharks nor that the sharks were in danger due to the tourists, it was a very chaotic and unnerving experience. Pair that with the fact that the staff was actively feeding them, and it’s not an activity you want to support. The sharks weren’t trapped there and could definitely leave, but they obviously opted to hang out for the free meal. It was really disappointing to see and participate in this. I hate that I paid money to this practice. Please stay away and find a more natural, ethical way to see whale sharks in the Philippines.
We were limited to 20-30 minutes in the water with the whale sharks to “protect” them, which I applaud, but I think it’s merely a convenient rule they enforce because it means they can charge and row a new group out to the spot immediately after. The place was packed. I’m sure they easily get 1,000 people out there each morning.