We were excited to try this restaurant after seeing it highly recommended by many different sites. On arrival on a Saturday evening it wasn't very busy and we were greeted promptly. We were seated and taken care of by our server Toni who was very...sweet and accommodating. We ordered some wine and soft drinks and the lobster ravioli to start. The lobster meat was decent, pasta cooked well, the cheese sauce was lacking and not flavorful. I ordered the angus burger cooked medium and my wife wanted to order the shrimp and scallop risotto but found that due to her allergy to black pepper the dish was already pre seasoned and she couldn't get that. This should have been an indication of what was going on in the kitchen. The website claims, "simple and honest cooking" "Fresh and Sustainable ingredients" and "Each dish reflects our passion for high quality food." How this is the case when a menu item cannot be cooked to order to avoid a spice, doesn't line up. Instead, she went with the Truffle cream cavatappi with added shrimp. The food arrived, the burger was overdone to a dry crispy patty, the cavatappi also had a tasteless sauce, the 5 large shrimp ($8 additional) were added to the dish, tails still on, were plump after having to pull them out of the sauce to remove the tails. Pasta and seafood are often amazing together, but this effort for a $26 dish was extremely disappointing. Toni did take back my burger and removed it from the check, we boxed the pasta and left. We had a wonderful day in Niagara prior to this dinner and won't be coming back to Wine on Third during any future visits.More